AVAILABLE FOR REPRINT. Copy and use freely. Please help PeaceVoice by notifying us when you use this piece: PeaceVoiceDirector@gmail.com
“I’m sitting in the aftermath of Paris, feeling emotions tear me apart. One of the emotions is joy. My daughter, who lives there, is safe.
Has “joy” ever felt so troubling?”
Author: Robert C. Koehler
Published in: Common Wonders Blog http://commonwonders.com/world/the-aftermath-of-paris/
Common Dreams http://www.commondreams.org/views/2015/11/19/shock-awe-aftermath-paris
The Smirking Chimp http://www.smirkingchimp.com/node/64861
Truth Out http://truth-out.org/buzzflash/commentary/remembering-that-the-us-terrorized-iraq-to-liberate-it-and-isis-was-born/19641-remembering-that-the-us-terrorized-iraq-to-liberate-it-and-isis-was-born
The Raven Foundation https://www.ravenfoundation.org/the-aftermath-of-paris/
Newberry Observer http://newberryobserver.com/opinion/columns/3448/the-aftermath-of-paris
Grassroots Press http://www.grass-roots-press.com/2015/11/22/the-aftermath-of-paris/
Huffington Post http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-koehler/the-aftermath-of-paris_b_8606176.html
Tribune Content Agency http://tribunecontentagency.com/article/the-aftermath-of-paris-r/
Cullman Sense http://www.cullmanstore.com/sites/default/files/CullmanSense-11-23-2015.pdf
Sierra County Prospect http://www.sierracountyprospect.org/2015/11/23/joy-feels-troubling-112515/
Gilmer Free Press http://www.gilmerfreepress.net/index.php/fpopin/the_aftermath_of_paris/
Times of Earth http://www.timesofearth.com/features-views-analysis/the-aftermath-of-paris.html
Las Vegas Informer lasvegas.informermg.com/2015/11/26/aftermath-paris
Date: November 19,22,22,23,26,27,2015
For the full article:
The Aftermath of Paris
By Robert C. Koehler
I’m sitting in the aftermath of Paris, feeling emotions tear me apart. One of the emotions is joy. My daughter, who lives there, is safe.
Has “joy” ever felt so troubling?
The aftermath of Paris seems likely to be intensified (“pitiless”) bombing raids in Syria, closed borders, heightened fear-based security and the deletion of “the gray zones of coexistence” across the planet.
Oh, it’s so nice to have an enemy who is truly evil! The logic of war is so seductive. It simplifies all these complex emotions. Just watch the news.
The news is that terror wins. Indeed, terror is the cornerstone of civilization.
I couldn’t get that notion out of my head. That’s because I couldn’t stop thinking about an act of extraordinary terror that took place a little more than a dozen years ago, and its relevance to the world’s current state of shock and chaos. Doing so made it impossible to contemplate the raw savagery of the ISIS killings in Paris and Beirut and everywhere else — the “my God!” of it all, as innocent lives are cut short with such indifference — in a simplistic context of us vs. them.
In March of 2003, the U.S. launched its invasion of Iraq with a bombing campaign called “Shock and Awe,” consisting of some 1,700 air sorties over the country that killed, according to Iraq Body Count, more than 7,400 civilians.
We launched our war on Iraq with the intent to commit terror on a scale ISIS could only dream of. The relevance of this is inescapable, not simply because it makes the United States and NATO brothers in terror with ISIS, but also because the war shattered Iraq and caused the death and displacement of millions more people and, ultimately, created the conditions in which ISIS was able to come to power.
What’s haunting to me is the absence of this shockingly relevant recent history from most mainstream coverage of the Paris killings — or more to the point, the absence of almost any sort of trans-war consciousness, you might say, from the discussion of what we ought to do next.
Considering that bombing campaigns, and war itself, are not only the equivalent of terror (“writ large”) but also wildly ineffective and counterproductive, producing, in the long term, pretty much the opposite of what rational, non-war-mongers crave, the failure of politicians and mainstream media types to reach beyond a riled militarism in their reaction to the Dark Ages terror in which ISIS specializes bodes poorly, I fear, for the future of humanity.
My daughter, who last Friday night had been at a rehearsal for an upcoming poetry event, found herself, at 10 p.m., as she was leaving a tavern called Les Caves St.-Sabin, in the middle of the chaos. As she and her friends stepped into the street, someone came running past warning people to get back inside. They only learned, in bits and pieces, the enormity of what was still happening in their city. She spent the night at the tavern, a decorated basement that felt, she said, like a “medieval fallout shelter.” In the morning, the Metro was running again, and she returned to her apartment. Only then did the horror hit her with full ferocity. She sat and cried, then got up and went to work.
However, the tears continue, if only in silence. The Paris tears are a small tributary to a worldwide River of Sorrow that swells beyond Paris and beyond Europe and the West to the broken, bombed, war-ravaged nations of the Third and Fourth World, the source of the planet’s 60 million refugees. This is the world of ISIS. Instead of continuing to bomb this world, in our fear and anger, we could try to understand it.
“ISIS is the first group since Al Qaeda to offer these young men a way to defend their dignity, family, and tribe.”
So wrote Lydia Wilson, a research fellow at the Centre for the Resolution of Intractable Conflict at Oxford University, in a recent piece for The Nation. She and her colleagues, in an attempt to do just that — understand those who have given over their lives to ISIS — recently interviewed ISIS prisoners of war in Iraq and, in the process, found their humanity. Mostly they were young men in their 20s who grew up in the wake of the American occupation of Iraq; that is to say, in the midst of brutal civil war.
“The Americans came,” one of them told her. “They took away Saddam, but they also took away our security. I didn’t like Saddam, we were starving then, but at least we didn’t have war. When you came here, the civil war started.”
Violence begets violence; war begets war. Knowing this is the starting place. It is time to start over.
Robert Koehler, syndicated by PeaceVoice, is a Chicago award-winning journalist and editor.
© 2023 PeaceVoice