AVAILABLE FOR REPRINT. Copy and use freely. Please help PeaceVoice by notifying us when you use this piece: PeaceVoiceDirector@gmail.com
“We are constantly assured that if we listen to the generals and the US intelligence officials, we will be well advised because they know so much more than we do. So how many failures of the generals and the intelligence officials do the American people endure before they turn to others—perhaps even those who study peace and nonviolent power—for a stronger and more helpful analysis? Advisers and colleagues of retired General David Petraeus say that he is approaching political and military leaders, advocating arming al Qaeda in Syria.”
Author: David Swanson
Published in: Let’s try democracy http://davidswanson.org/node/4894
The Real News http://therealnews.com/t2/component/content/article/72-more-blog-posts-from-david-swanson/2501-12-questions-for-general-petraeus-on-his-support-for-al-qaeda
Gilmer Free Press http://www.gilmerfreepress.net/index.php/fpopin/12_questions_for_general_petraeus_on_his_support_for_al_qaeda/
The Smirking Chimp http://www.therussophile.org/12-questions-for-general-petraeus-on-his-support-for-al-qaeda.html/
Date: September 1,7,2015
For the full article:
12 Questions for General Petraeus on His Support for Al Qaeda
475 words
By David Swanson
We are constantly assured that if we listen to the generals and the US intelligence officials, we will be well advised because they know so much more than we do. So how many failures of the generals and the intelligence officials do the American people endure before they turn to others—perhaps even those who study peace and nonviolent power—for a stronger and more helpful analysis? Advisers and colleagues of retired General David Petraeus say that he is approaching political and military leaders, advocating arming al Qaeda in Syria.
Now that General David Petraeus wants to arm and train al Qaeda killers, a number of questions arise that might be raised with the great leader:
1. Should people who said that anyone was a traitor who called you David Betray-Us while you were fighting al Qaeda, now call you David Betray-Us or a traitor?
2. Do you imagine that just because you can share all sorts of secrets with your girlfriend and get off easy, there are no hardcore nut cases who believe in the “material support for terrorism” law more than they believe in you?
3. Have you looked into whether this West Point professor wants you shot?
4. The U.S. armed what would become al Qaeda against the Soviet Union. Al Qaeda in Iraq developed into ISIS following U.S. war-making there. Could arming one branch of Al Qaeda against another really be the way violence at long last, for the first time, produces something other than more violence?
5. Is this part of a revival of Ronald Reagan traditional conservatism?
6. Do you foresee arming ISIS against a different, greater evil, as a possible future policy? If so, is the Pentagon justified in having gotten a head start on that?
7. Did you know that the U.S. public revolt against a proposed war on Syria in 2013 was driven in part by opposition to aligning with al Qaeda?
8. Is the problem here overly successful propaganda? Should future wars be marketed without the same level of promotion of an enemy brand?
9. When recruiting people to commit mass murder, are you seriously going to keep claiming that what you’re looking for are the “moderates”?
10. While avoiding arms embargoes, disarmament, cease-fires, aid, diplomacy, or peace at all costs, and always arming new groups, you either have to continually invent new groups (like Khorasan) or eventually come around to arming some of the groups you previously armed others against. Which raises the question: which weapons maker loves you the very most?
11. Have you shifted strategy from bribing people not to fight to bribing people to fight because the success of the former turned out to be so fleeting? Why would the latter work better?
12. You have the right to remain silent. Do you understand this right? Have you ever considered exercising it?
__________
David Swanson writes for PeaceVoice, is director of WorldBeyondWar.org and campaign coordinator for RootsAction.org. Swanson’s books include War Is A Lie.
© 2023 PeaceVoice
peacevoice